Assumption 1
The app design looks dated compared to other similar shopping apps, such as Facebook Marketplace or eBay.
Assumption 2
The app has poor usability because of an insufficient visual hierarchy between information and too much information on one page.
Testing The Hypothesis
- Survey
User interviews were conducted with millenials who are the main users of Gumtree. We found most millenials think Gumtree has a strong brand identity but needs to be more reliable and easier to use.
Redesign Goal
Clear Hierarchy and Layout
Personalised Service
Enhance User Credibility
Time Saving Communication Process
We conducted secondary research to deepen our understanding of the target audience and discover their needs.
Key Findings
(Source: Gumtree Report 2021)
68%
68% of millennials are concerned about their ability to pay for household expenses such as food, utility bills and internet, compared to only 53% of Baby Boomers.
$7,000
Millennials have 17 unwanted items on average and the highest estimated value of unwanted items ($7,000).
$9,000
Millennials achieved top average earnings per seller ($9,000) in 2020.
60%
60% of millennials buy something second hand at least once a year or more.
We analysed Facebook Marketplace and eBay as direct competitors to develop effective redesign strategies. They both had a well-designed website and application interface. And they also had their own distinctive features that help users make a decision quickly and feel engaged.
Main Functions
Competitive Reviews
Distinctive Features
We interviewed 10 people to better understand their experiences, not only with similar marketplaces but also the Gumtree app, and what they consider importantly when buying used items. Key findings and quotes regarding Gumtree app.
Interview findings
Navigation
Too much information causes fatigue and makes it hard to navigate in the app.
Seller’s Info
90% of interviewees consider seller’s information important for judging their reliability.
Review and Rating
70% of interviewees think that reviews and ratings are key factors when deciding seller’s credibility.
AI Recommendations
75% of interviewees prefer personalised AI recommendation when they use a shopping website/app.
Key quotes regarding Gumtree app
"The app is a bit crowded with options and too much things are happening on the screen."
"Variability in photo/text formatting used by different sellers makes the app look messy, the listings advertised on the main page are a bit weird."
"Too many wordy categories are annoying, make users think too much."
"I don’t feel engaged in this platform. Feel like I’m using just temporarily for a specific purpose sometimes."
Based on findings from the survey, three distinct personas (buyer, seller, and browser) were created to keep design decisions aligned with the user’s needs.
Combining all insights from our research results, four key pain points and solutions to solve these issues were defined.
01. Poor Navigation / Unclear Interface
Time wasted sorting through unnecessary categories
02. Lack of Customised Experience
Random item listings unrelated to user’s interest
03. Unreliable Transaction Process
Unverified users
Insufficient seller’s ratings and review
04. Time Consuming Communication
Limited number of pre-defined questions to choose from
Message function unavailable on a listing page
To plan how the app will function, we mapped the basic flow of main functions to determine what steps users need to take to reach a goal.
Information Architecture was built to illustrate the overall navigation structure and highlight what has been updated.
Elements in purple have been updated.
Low & high fidelity wireframes were created to develop ideas and gain feedback from users. Uncovered frictions led to further refinements and improvements towards a user friendly design and more intuitive navigation.
Main Palette
#353535
#3BAA33
#ffffff
#f2f2f2
Secondary Palette
#36263B
#72EF37
#DD5644
Before
After
There wasn’t any option for customising the item listings when users make a new account before redesign.Once users choose the location and the categories that they want to trade, optimised item listings will be shown on the main page.
Reflection
Future Steps
In a later update, we would like to run quick unmoderated usability tests, like first-click tests, session recordings and 5-second tests, to ensure the user flow is intuitive and the app is easy to navigate.
And we would apply these redesigned features to other Gumtree services for an integrated user experience across the Gumtree platform.
What did you learn?
As product designers, we learnt to design the app based on user needs and feedback rather than personal preference. We had to change some of our initial ideas as these were not ideal for users. Having conducted our own research, including user interviews and gathering feedback, we gained insights that helped us develop a product we believe would provide more efficient and reliable service.
What would you have done differently?
Given more time, we would have conducted user interview with more people and also one-to-one in depth interviews to more comprehensively characterise user’s pain points and needs.In addition, we would have included motion graphics and further illustrations to make the app more engaging and dynamic, and enable users to navigate the app in a more enjoyable way.